Why is the SEC the best football conference in the country? The SEC has won five of the last 12 national Titles. To put this into perspective- no other conference has posted more than three national titles during this run. Perennial big game losers Oklahoma and Ohio State have both lost two national titles in the last 12 years. Why is this important? Simply put, the Big 12 and Big 10 (11 schools in the Big 10) are very top heavy. This basically guarantees their conference winner a berth in the national championship game with little or no interference by teams within their conference.
Ohio State only has to beat Michigan and Oklahoma only has to beat Texas or in reverse order to receive a berth in the national title game. The SEC on the other has more vicious conference play. Every weekend is a war and the battle is not over until after the SEC Championship game winner is crowned. The SEC has four head coaches who have won national championships within the conference. Two of the four are now coaching at different schools (Steve Spurrier, formerly Florida, currently South Carolina, and Nick Saban, formerly LSU, currently, Alabama).
The SEC has nine teams that can claim with straight faces that they will compete to win their respective divisions this season. The Big 12 might be a mile wide in terms of its talent at the top, but it doesn't go very deep. As of two weeks ago, The SEC had five teams in the top ten in national polls. The only reason some have fallen from grace, this early in the year, is the remarkable depth that the SEC displays. Alabama beat number 3 ranked Georgia at home and Florida fell victim to a good Ole Miss team that is two plays away from being undefeated. Conversely, because of the argument I have just stated some may say well the Big 12 has three teams in the top five. The problem with this is the fact that Missouri, Oklahoma and Texas have yet to play any notable games this year. The Big 12 logjam at the top of the polls will end quickly once conference is underway. Could you honestly let yourself believe that Oklahoma and Texas would be half as good if they resided in either division of the SEC?
The SEC East is tough as nails where Florida, Georgia, Kentucky and surprising Vandy are all having good runs. South Carolina and Tennessee have the talent to beat you on any given Saturday as well. This year the power resides in the West though as Alabama, LSU, Auburn, and Ole Miss are contenders for the division's title There are only two teams that are not competitive in the SEC and they are Arkansas, which usually is stiff completion more often than not, and Mississippi State which is having major injury problems.
The resurgence of the Big 12 North only began last year when Kansas and Missouri made large jumps in order to be among the nation's top programs. Nebraska and Colorado are at least a year away. Leaving ISU and KSU terrible at best. The Big 12 South has always been and always will be a two horse race between Oklahoma and Texas. Texas Tech may have a decent team this year, but have yet to play for the conference crown since the Big 12 started in 1996. Furthermore, with their pass defense being ranked near the worst in the country, they will not be a factor in the final standings- as usual. Texas A&M is a sleeping giant, but how long is it going to take for the Aggies to wake up? I guess this has turned into a Big 12 vs. the SEC article and the truth of the matter is that the Big 12 clearly has the second best talent in the country but does not come close to the SEC.
Go back to 1995, to find the last instance an SEC team lost a national championship game when given the opportunity. This leads me to the thought process that if an SEC team is good enough to win their conference and go undefeated they have about a 99% chance of beating whoever their opponent from a weaker conference may be. Auburn was robbed of playing for a national title a few years back even though they did get throught thier schedule undefeated. Need more proof? The SEC won all four of its BCS games the past two years by a combined score of 161-62.
Another way of analyzing this situation is evaluating the respective conferences performances in non-conference battles this year. The Big 12 boasts an overall 38-10 non-conference mark, with the SEC coasting to 27-5. You are only as strong as your weakest link. The SEC proves time and time again that the only thing stopping an SEC team is another SEC opponent.
A coach at the University of Oklahoma who previously coached at Alabama, but will remain unnamed told me once, "down there in the SEC, it's just different, it's on a way bigger scale, the talent, the fans, and the stadiums- the Big 12 just doesn't compare." Um, Need I say more?
Sincerely, COWBOY CLAYBORNE of the Philadelphia Claybornes